Tuesday, March 23, 2010

More Americans Killed In Mexico.

MEXICO CITY (AP) — More Americans in Mexico are falling victim to a wave of drug violence sweeping the country, a change driven home by the recent killing of a U.S. Consulate employee and her husband who were gunned down after leaving a children's birthday party.
The number of U.S. citizens killed in Mexico has more than doubled to 79 in 2009 from 35 in 2007, according to the U.S. State Department's annual count. No figures were available for the first two months of 2010.
While only some of the killings are specifically listed as "executions" or "drug-related," the increase in homicides appears to be related to drug battles. In Ciudad Juarez, the northern border city hardest hit by drug violence and where the consulate employee was killed, homicides of Americans rose to 23 in 2009 from two in 2007.
The annual murder rate for the estimated 500,000 American citizens in Mexico at any one time has risen — but still remains lower than in some U.S. cities: about 15 per 100,000. Baltimore's 2009 homicide rate was 37 per 100,000 residents.
American deaths make up only a tiny fraction of Mexico's 17,900 drug-related killings since December 2006, when President Felipe Calderon launched a military-led drug war.
On Saturday, a clash among armed men left eight people dead in the Pacific coast state of Sinaloa. The bodies of seven men were found inside two cars along a highway connecting the cities of Culiacan and Mazatlan, said Sinaloa prosecutors' spokesman Martin Gastelum. An eighth victim, dressed in a fake federal police uniform and holding a grenade, was found near the cars, Gastelum said.
The government says the majority of those killed in Mexico's drug violence were involved in the narcotics trade. But an increasing number of bystanders are dying in the crossfire, and Americans are among them.
Tania Lozoya, 15, of El Paso, Texas, was killed by a stray bullet at her aunt's house across the border in Ciudad Juarez in May 2009, after gunfire broke out when two men chased another man into the backyard of the residence.
In December 2009, a California assistant school principal, Augustin Salcedo, was killed after he was abducted from a restaurant along with five other men while he and his wife were visiting her hometown of Gomez Palacio, in the northern state of Durango. The motive for the mass abduction remains unclear.
Other Americans appear to have been specifically targeted.
U.S. anti-kidnapping expert Felix Batista was abducted by gunmen in December 2008 in the northern city of Saltillo, where he had gone to advise local businessmen on how to avoid becoming victims of the country's wave of kidnappings. He has not been found.
"I see it as, my brother was interfering with their profit margin," said Batista's sister, Jackie Batista. "That's their line of business. Other than drugs, it's kidnapping, so people want to know how to keep themselves safe, and that intrudes into their profit margin."
More than a year after his disappearance, nobody knows for sure who took Batista.
The prosecutors' office in the state of Coahuila, where Saltillo is located, confirmed that no trace of Batista has been found, and they now appear to consider it an inactive case.
"I think that's my biggest fear," Batista said. "That this case will never be resolved. ... Excuse the phrase, and I hate to use it, that it has gone to the grave with those people who were involved."
Americans whose relatives have become victims of Mexico's drug war have established an informal group to support one another and stay informed about what is happening south of the border. "America needs to wake up and smell the kidnappings, smell the drug war," Batista says.
She frequently keeps in touch with San Antonio, Texas resident Jose Esparza, whose two brothers and sister were kidnapped in the northern Mexico town of Cuencame more than a year ago; all were U.S. residents and had spouses or children who are U.S. citizens. As with Felix Batista, there has been no request for ransom, and no sign of the victims.
Esparza says that in Texas alone he has heard from about 10 other people with relatives or friends who disappeared in Mexico.
He and others say they have obtained little or no response from Mexican authorities. Esparza now places his faith in the possibility the U.S. may begin to directly investigate the cases.
"Unless the U.S. government gets involved, nothing is ever going to happen," he said.
FBI officials are aiding Mexican authorities in the investigation into the March 13 killings of U.S. consular employee Lesley A. Enriquez, 35, who was four months pregnant, and her husband, Arthur H. Redelfs, 34.
They were gunned down in their white SUV on a Ciudad Juarez street as they were leaving the birthday party of a child of a U.S. Consulate employee. Their 7-month-old daughter was found wailing in the back of the vehicle.
Investigators are following several lines of investigation as to why gunmen followed the couple's vehicle and a second white SUV that left the same party and was hit in a separate, nearly simultaneous attack. Jorge Alberto Salcido, the husband of a Mexican employee of the consulate, was killed in that assault.
One theory being investigated is that assailants may have been ordered to attack a white SUV, staked out the wrong party and then opened fire on the wrong vehicles.
Another line of investigation is that Redelfs may have been targeted because of his work at an El Paso prison, which is holding several members of the Aztecas gang, believed responsible for the attacks.
More than 200 federal, state and local law enforcement officers swept through El Paso on Thursday, picking up suspected members of the gang in an effort to find new leads in the killings.
Ciudad Juarez Mayor Jose Reyes does not think the victims were targeted because of their U.S. ties. "I do not think this was a message to the consulate," Reyes said.
But Enriquez's cousin Vicky Torres doesn't see it that way.
"It's a message for the United States, like a challenge: 'Don't you mess around, you Americans, because this will happen,'" she said.
Lourdes Batista, the kidnap victim's wife, says she hopes the crimes will be a wake-up call for the American public.
"I pray that it will be," she said. "We're fighting a war across a big ocean, but what about here? What about our neighbor
?"

Sunday, March 21, 2010

A Good Beginning.



Caught in the cross-hairs of California's state budget crisis, the Los Angeles Superior Court — the largest trial court system in the nation — this week laid off 329 employees and closed 16 courtrooms. Facing an unprecedented $79 million shortfall, Presiding Judge Charles W. McCoy said that the courts will lay-off an additional 500 workers and shutter up to a total of 50 courtrooms come September. Announcing the cutbacks in a courtroom closed months ago to save money, McCoy said, "Today is a sad day for justice in Los Angeles." With attrition, McCoy expects the 5,400-employee court system to lose approximately 1,000 employees, a 20% reduction.

The 16 closed courtrooms handled criminal, family law, civil law along with complex litigation and small claims case loads. Similar cuts are taking place in courts across the state. McCoy says the 100,000 Angelenos who use the courts each day can expect growing case backlogs, longer lines and delays in processing judgments. Among those losing their jobs: clerks, court reporters and supervisors. Judge Marjorie Steinberg says her family law departments are losing mental health professionals who help parents negotiate their disputes before they go to court: "You can imagine how tough that is on a family, and on the children, whose parents are fighting."

The courts, which make up 2% of the state budget, have thus joined the slash-and-cut regimen that has befallen school districts, cities, and social services across California as the state deals with a $21 billion shortfall this year. (That comes on the heels of last year's $40 billion deficit.)

The trial system will not be affected uniformly. Statutory and constitutional guarantees in the criminal justice system protect the right to a speedy trial, says Allan Parachini, spokesman for the Los Angeles Superior Court, so "we really can't go to the criminal courts for the cuts... what is happening is that resources are being bled out of other areas, especially civil, to make sure we can meet all our obligations in criminal." Ten years ago the average time to trial in a general civil case in Los Angeles County was an eye popping five years. Reforms and increased efficiency reduced the wait to 16 months but Parachini says he expects civil case delays to spike again.

"In addition to the impact on the civil courts, our family and juvenile courts are about to take huge hits," says Don Mike Anthony, president of the Los Angeles County Bar Association. He says custody orders, divorce and child support matters that now take 30 days will soon take four months. In addition, the court will no longer provide financial support and supervising personnel to the Court-Appointed Special Advocates (CASA) program which works on behalf of abused, neglected and abandoned children involved in dependency court matters. Among the mundane cuts, a reduction of the popular night traffic court from twice to once a month.

"We have explored every financial scenario before taking this action, but more than 80% of our budget goes to salaries and benefits, which forces today's drastic measures," said McCoy. With annual court budget deficits expected to be as high as $140 million over the next four years, court officials say up to 1,800 staff positions may be eliminated. Last year, the California judicial council instituted a one-day per month closure of all state courts as both a cost-savings.
A series of unprecedented statewide court closures one day each month, while necessary to deal with California's budget crisis, will also bring unwanted case delays to thousands beginning this week, San Francisco's presiding superior court judge said today.

"This is not a proud day for us," Judge James McBride said at a news conference at San Francisco's civil courthouse. The court is one of several in San Francisco and throughout California that will close this Wednesday, and every third Wednesday through June of next year.

But McBride said the decision, made in July by the California Judicial Council, which oversees the state court system, was "the only rational choice to make," as opposed to "massive layoffs" of experienced court employees or cuts in court programs.

The closures, the equivalent of a new court holiday during which employees will not be paid, will affect each of the superior courts of California's 58 counties, as well as the six regional appeals courts and the California Supreme Court.

"We will be, in that week, cramming five days' work into four," McBride said.

"The work's not going to go away," he said.

The Judicial Council ordered the furlough days to help close the state judicial system's estimated $414 million deficit, which McBride called a "devastating crash in our budget."
The closures will save an estimated $94.3 million.

Many state judges, including in San Francisco, have also reportedly agreed to voluntary 5-percent salary givebacks to the courts. Superior court judges in California are paid approximately $179,000 per year.

"The unintended yet inevitable symbolism of 'Closed' signs on our courthouses — institutions that embody our nation's revered democratic ideas — is a graphic indication of the severity of California's economic crisis," said California Chief Justice Ronald George addressing the state legislature last year. "For many Californians the courts represent their primary — and sometimes their most important — interaction with state government. Courts are not a luxury to be funded in good times and ignored in bad times."

Meanwhile, the negative economic ripple effect of cuts to the Los Angeles civil courts could result in a nearly $30 billion hit to the local economy over the next four years, according to a study commissioned by the Los Angeles Superior Court. According to the study, the legal services industry would take an estimated $13 billion loss and businesses operating in uncertainty, because of pending civil disputes, would accumulate another $15 billion in potential losses. The decline in economic activity would then result in an additional $1.6 billion in losses.

A Sacramento judge who fought the once-a-month court closures by the state Judicial Council said the action is unwarranted locally and will result in monstrous new backlogs.

Superior Court Judge Maryanne G. Gilliard said the state could have made up the $94.3 million saved with the closures by cutting the Judicial Council's operational arm, the Administrative Office of the Courts, and scrapping a $1.1 billion computer system that many local judges have harshly criticized.

"I think that statewide closure of the courts by order of the Judicial Council is unprecedented and, beyond that, is unwarranted, especially in light of the fact that there are obvious areas in the AOC's own budget that could have been tapped in order to not restrict the public's constitutional right of access to their courts," Gilliard said in an interview in her chambers.

"This was an unnecessary order," she said.

The judge blasted the growth of the court administrative office's budget from $100 million to $177 million over the past five years and its increase in employees from 491 to 785. Agency officials have defended the increases as a reflection of their taking over executive authority for court operations throughout the state.

Gilliard said that as many as 20 county court systems in the state, including Sacramento's, have the resources to stay in operation and avoid the closures.

"We could keep our doors open, but we're being told we have to shut down because it's more important that there be uniformity rather than access to justice and the courts for those counties able to do so," she said.

In Sacramento, backlogged local courts have forced civil trials into years-long delays and Gilliard said the shutdown will extend delays to other areas.

"Let's talk about abused and neglected children whose cases are going to be delayed," Gilliard said. "Let's talk about crime victims. Let's talk about those accused of crimes. Let's talk about jurors who could be very well in the midst of deliberations on a murder trial being told they have to go home.

"It is significant, and the public should be aware that the Thursday after the Wednesday shutdowns, it's going to be monstrous in terms of dealing with the press of cases (that) we're not going to be able to get to on Wednesday," she said.

An LA Times editorial said that: With the potentially catastrophic effects of court closures and layoffs on our economy, you'd think that the Judicial Council, the statewide body that oversees courts, and its administrative agency, the AOC, would make solving this problem their top priority.

Unfortunately, the AOC and the Judicial Council have busied themselves with other tasks. An unfinished, $2-billion IT project, for example, has mushroomed over the last several years to more than five times its originally projected cost. There's no direct oversight of AOC's budget, no independent audits, no access to its internal records and no whistle-blowing protection for staff. In short, it's an entity that receives special legal protection by the state to operate outside the realm of public scrutiny and accountability, a status the justices who oversee it fiercely protect. The problem is so bad that in just one year, and with no staffing or budget, an organization of dissident judges who want more accountability for the AOC and Judicial Council has already signed on more than 10% of all state judges.

Monday, March 15, 2010

U.S. Consulate Workers Killed In Mexico Drug War.

First there was Bobby Salcedo form El Monte, California on New Year's Eve 2010. Being a School Board Member he was the first American elected official to be murdered in Mexico. On 13 March the Mexican Drug murders of Americans took an ominous turn.

The drug wars in Mexico took an ominous turn when a U.S. consulate employee and her husband were killed as they left a children's birthday party in Ciudad Juarez, Mexico's most violent city. Only minutes earlier gunmen also killed the Mexican husband of another member of the consular staff and wounded his two children.

While a number of US citizens have been killed in Mexico's increasingly bloody drug wars between rival cartels, it is the first time an American government employee has been killed.

President Barack Obama has expressed outrage over the killings, and Mexican President Felipe Calderon promised a swift investigation.

The three died during one of the bloodiest weekends so far in Mexico, with nearly 50 people murdered in gang violence. Another 13 people were killed in a gangland shoot-out in the Pacific resort city of Acapulco on Sunday.

The US consulate employee and her husband, identified as Lesley Enriquez, 35, and Athur Redelfs, 39, were shot to death on Saturday 13 March 2010 in their car near the Santa Fe International bridge linking Ciudad Juarez with El Paso, Texas.

According to the newspaper Diario de Juarez, gunmen chased the couple's white van shortly after 2 p.m. on Saturday, shooting at the vehicle until it swerved out of control, crashing into oncoming traffic near the bridge.

Ms Enriquez, who was four months pregnant with the couple's second child, was shot in the head, while her husband was shot in his neck and arm. When police officers arrived at the victims' bullet-riddled Toyota van, they discovered the couple's baby daughter crying disconsolately in the back seat, Diario de Juarez reported. At first the officers thought the seven-month-old girl had been wounded, but she was unharmed.

"This is shocking to everyone," Reuben Redelfs, the brother of the victim, told the Washington Post. "People need to know what's going on down here. It's become a war zone ..... It's just horrible what's happening."

At approximately the same time, the third victim, Jorge Alberto Salcido Ceniceros, 37, was killed as he travelled in another part of Juarez. The gunmen boxed in the man's car, shot him and wounded his two children, aged four and seven, according to media reports.

The attacks occurred as the US State Department was taking the unusual step of authorizing U.S. government employees at Ciudad Juarez and five other American consulates in northern Mexico to send their families out of the region because of concerns over the increasing bloodshed. That announcement was in the works before the murders, officials said.

President Obama was "deeply saddened and outraged" by the killings, the White House said.

"He extends his condolences to the families and condemns these attacks on consular and diplomatic personnel serving at our foreign missions," a White House statement said. "In concert with Mexican authorities, we will work tirelessly to bring their killers to justice."

Mr Calderon's office said the Mexican president "expresses his indignation" and "his sincerest condolences to the families of the victims." He "reiterated the Mexican government's unwavering compromise to resolve these grave crimes."

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton extended her sympathy to the families of the victims and said Washington would continue to work with the Mexican government to bring drug traffickers to justice.

"These appalling assaults on members of our own State Department family are, sadly, part of a growing tragedy besetting many communities in Mexico," said Mrs Clinton. Washington was committed to: "work closely with the government of President Calderon to cripple the influence of trafficking organizations at work in Mexico," she said.

Ciudad Juarez a city of 1.3 million people just across the US border from El Paso, is at the epicentre of the drug wars that have devastated Mexico over recent years. In the last three years alone, 15,000 people have been murdered, many of them in turf wars between rival drug gans.

At least 18,000 people have been killed in Mexico since December 2006, when Mexican President Felipe Calderon deployed the army to battle increasingly powerful traffickers.

Alarmed by the brazen shootings, the State Department announced Sunday that employees at a string of U.S. consular offices along the Mexican border — Tijuana, Nogales, Ciudad Juárez, Nuevo Laredo, Monterrey and Matamoros — could evacuate their families to the United States.

The consular agency in Reynosa was temporarily closed in recent weeks after violence in that city grew.

Strengthening its travel warning for Mexico, the State Department said, "While most crime victims are Mexican citizens, the uncertain security situation poses serious risks for U.S. citizens as well."

Social Security to Start Cashing Federal Government's IOUs

PARKERSBURG, W.Va. – The retirement nest egg of an entire generation is stashed away in this small town along the Ohio River: $2.5 trillion in IOUs from the federal government, payable to the Social Security Administration.

It's time to start cashing them in.

For more than two decades, Social Security collected more money in payroll taxes than it paid out in benefits — billions more each year.

Not anymore. This year, for the first time since the 1980s, when Congress last overhauled Social Security, the retirement program is projected to pay out more in benefits than it collects in taxes — nearly $29 billion more.

Sounds like a good time to start tapping the nest egg. Too bad the federal government already spent that money over the years on other programs, preferring to borrow from Social Security rather than foreign creditors. In return, the Treasury Department issued a stack of IOUs — in the form of Treasury bonds — which are kept in a nondescript office building just down the street from Parkersburg's municipal offices.

Now the government will have to borrow even more money, much of it abroad, to start paying back the IOUs, and the timing couldn't be worse. The government is projected to post a record $1.5 trillion budget deficit this year, followed by trillion dollar deficits for years to come.

Social Security's shortfall will not affect current benefits. As long as the IOUs last, benefits will keep flowing. But experts say it is a warning sign that the program's finances are deteriorating. Social Security is projected to drain its trust funds by 2037 unless Congress acts, and there's concern that the looming crisis will lead to reduced benefits.

"This is not just a wake-up call, this is it. We're here," said Mary Johnson, a policy analyst with The Senior Citizens League, an advocacy group. "We are not going to be able to put it off any more."

For more than two decades, regardless of which political party was in power, Congress has been accused of raiding the Social Security trust funds to pay for other programs, masking the size of the budget deficit.

Remember Al Gore's "lockbox," the one he was going to use to protect Social Security? The former vice president talked about it so much during the 2000 presidential campaign that he was parodied on "Saturday Night Live."

Gore lost the election and never got his lockbox. But to illustrate the government's commitment to repaying Social Security, the Treasury Department has been issuing special bonds that earn interest for the retirement program. The bonds are unique because they are actually printed on paper, while other government bonds exist only in electronic form.

They are stored in a three-ring binder, locked in the bottom drawer of a white metal filing cabinet in the Parkersburg offices of Bureau of Public Debt. The agency, which is part of the Treasury Department, opened offices in Parkersburg in the 1950s as part of a plan to locate important government functions away from Washington, D.C., in case of an attack during the Cold War.

One bond is worth a little more than $15.1 billion and another is valued at just under $10.7 billion. In all, the agency has about $2.5 trillion in bonds, all backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. But don't bother trying to steal them; they're nonnegotiable, which means they are worthless on the open market.

More than 52 million people receive old age or disability benefits from Social Security. The average benefit for retirees is a little under $1,200 a month. Disabled workers get an average of $1,100 a month.

Social Security is financed by payroll taxes — employers and employees must each pay a 6.2 percent tax on workers' earnings up to $106,800. Retirees can start getting early, reduced benefits at age 62. They get full benefits if they wait until they turn 66. Those born after 1960 will have to wait until they turn 67.

Social Security's financial problems have been looming for years as the nation's 78 million baby boomers approached retirement age. The oldest are already there. As that huge group of people starts collecting benefits — and stops paying payroll taxes — Social Security's trust funds will shrink, running out of money by 2037, according to the latest projection from the trustees who oversee the program.

The recession is making things worse, at least in the short term. Tax receipts are down from the loss of more than 8 million jobs, and applications for early retirement benefits have spiked from older workers who were laid off and forced to retire.

Stephen C. Goss, chief actuary for the Social Security Administration, says the crisis has been years in the making. "If this helps get people to look more seriously at that in the nearer term, that's probably a good thing. But it's only really a punctuation mark on the fact that we have longer-term financial issues that need to be addressed."

In the short term, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office projects that Social Security will continue to pay out more in benefits than it collects in taxes for the next three years. It is projected to post small surpluses of $6 billion each in 2014 and 2015, before returning to indefinite deficits in 2016.

For the budget year that ends in September, Social Security is projected to collect $677 million in taxes and spend $706 million on benefits and expenses.

Social Security will also collect about $120 billion in interest on the trust funds, according to the CBO projections, meaning its overall balance sheet will continue to grow. The interest, however, is paid by the government, adding even more to the budget deficit.

While Congress must shore up the program, action is unlikely this year, said Rep. Earl Pomeroy, D-N.D., who just took over last week as chairman of the House subcommittee that oversees Social Security.

"The issues required to address the long-term solvency needs of Social Security can be done in a careful, thoughtful and orderly way and they don't need to be done in the next few months," Pomeroy said.

The national debt — the amount of money the government owes its creditors — is about $12.5 trillion, or nearly $42,000 for every man, woman and child in the country. About $8 trillion has been borrowed in public debt markets, much of it from foreign creditors. The rest came from various government trust funds, including retirement funds for civil servants and the military. About $2.5 trillion is owed to Social Security.

Good luck to the politician who reneges on that debt, said Barbara Kennelly, a former Democratic congresswoman from Connecticut who is now president of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare.

"Those bonds are protected by the full faith and credit of the United States of America," Kennelly said. "They're as solid as what we owe China and Japan."

___

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Treasury Dept Targets Older Americans On Fixed Income.

Social Security Checks Getting Smaller
Govt to Collect Old Loans and Debts from Social Security Benefits


A little–noticed law could soon result in smaller Social Security checks for hundreds of thousands of the elderly and disabled who owe the U.S. money from defaulted loans and other debts more than a decade old.

Social Security benefits are off–limits to creditors, such as credit–card companies and banks. But the U.S. can collect debts to federal agencies by "offsetting," or withholding Social Security and disability payments.

The Treasury currently withholds benefits of 3.1 million Social Security recipients to recover defaulted student–, farm– and small–business loans, unpaid income taxes, amounts veterans owe for health care, and other debts to the government.

Previously, the U.S. hasn't been able to withhold Social Security payments to recover most debts delinquent for more than ten years.

But a provision in the 2008 Farm Bill lifted the ten–year statute of limitations on the government's ability to withhold Social Security benefits in collecting debts other than student loans—for which the statute of limitations was lifted in 1997—and income taxes, where the limit remains 10 years.

This means that a person who defaulted on a small–business loan in 1995, for example, and who is receiving Social Security could be notified that his benefits may be reduced each month until the debt, with interest, fees, and penalties, is paid. The Treasury can withhold 15% of the benefit, though it can't be reduced to below $750. Tax debts have no floor.

The change will add more than $6 billion to the $75 billion in delinquent debt individuals owe the government, according to the Financial Management Service, the Treasury's debt collection unit.

A Treasury spokesman says the new legislation "allows Treasury's Financial Management Service to collect older debts and levels the playing field so that all eligible debts, regardless of age, are subject to debt collection. Treasury expects this legislation will result in increased collections of $10 million per year in delinquent federal non–tax debt."

Though no one argues that people shouldn't repay their debts, the change is coming at a challenging time for older Americans already pinched by mortgage woes, pension cuts and spiraling medical costs.

The shift applies to debtors of all ages, but Social Security recipients will bear much of the brunt. A Wall Street Journal analysis of Treasury Department data shows that Social Security recipients comprise a large and growing percentage of people from whom the Treasury recovers debts.

For years, most debt the Treasury collected through its "Offset Program," came from withholding income–tax refunds. But with an aging population and growing unemployment, roughly 10% of the $4.3 billion in debts collected by the Treasury came from Social Security benefits in 2008, the latest figures available. That's up from 1.6% in 2001, according to Journal computations that the Treasury confirms.

Though the law has expanded the age of debts that can be recovered, it hasn't addressed the sometimes–Kafkaesque process debtors can face when challenging the validity of a claim.

Consider the predicament of Dr. Robert Steinberg, the founder of Scharffen Berger chocolates, who spent more than six years and thousands of dollars in legal fees appealing the Social Security Administration's claim that he owed it more than $28,000.

Dr. Steinberg received disability benefits in the early 1990s while undergoing chemotherapy for lymphoma, a condition that ultimately claimed his life. Dr. Steinberg returned to work sporadically at a free clinic before co–founding the chocolate company.

Year later, the Social Security Administration notified Dr. Steinberg he was overpaid in the 1990s. In May 2002, with the matter still unresolved, the agency turned the debt over to the Treasury for collection.

In Oct. 2002, administrative law judge Gary Lee found that the Social Security Administration had never established the amount of the overpayment; had dismissed an earlier appeal "for spurious reasons"; had misinformed Dr. Steinberg and mishandled his later appeals; and had lost his file. He noted that Dr. Steinberg was "without fault," and told the agency to stop its collections efforts.

Dr. Steinberg died in 2008, at 61. His lawyer, Peter Young, a former staff attorney for the Social Security Administration, has handled more than 100 overpayment cases, "very few of which were accurate," he says. "Most people can't find or afford help, and give up very quickly and end up with painful offsets on a fixed budget."

An agency spokeswoman says mistakes can happen, but "over all, the process works."

A Treasury spokesman says the new regulations require agencies seeking to recover debts more than a decade old to give debtors the right to review and copy their files, make payment arrangements, and apply for disability and hardship waivers.

But a recent dispute about a student loan shows that even with these rights, a person challenging an old debt can face hurdles similar to homeowners in foreclosure trying to modify a loan that has been resold.

In 2003, the U.S. began withholding $173 a month in Social Security benefits from Annie Brown, a paralyzed 75–year–old widow living in a nursing home to repay a defaulted $8,823 student loan the Education Department says she took out in 1989. The offset reduced Mrs. Brown's benefit to about $980 a month.

Mrs. Brown said a granddaughter had forged her signature on a loan application. Her daughter and a lawyer spent more than four years disputing the debt with the owner of the loan, United Student Aid Funds, a student–loan guarantor that also was acting as one of the Education Department's 21 debt collectors. USA Funds itself farms out various debt–collection activities to others, which it did in Mrs. Brown's case.

Between 2003 and 2008, Mrs. Brown's daughter and Lynn Drysdale, a legal–aid lawyer in Jacksonville, Fla., corresponded numerous times with USA Funds and two other debt–collection companies it hired. One letter from USA Funds warned that unless documents were received "within 30 days from the date this letter was generated...your case will be closed." The letter was undated. Another letter required Mrs. Brown to refer to an attached document. There was no attachment. "I don't know how a lay person could maneuver through this process," says Ms. Drysdale. "Nobody seemed to know what was needed."

In 2007, USA Funds denied Mrs. Brown's claim, citing a recently passed federal rule requiring people claiming identity theft on student loans to obtain a criminal court verdict of the crime. That was impossible for Mrs. Brown; a statute of limitations for bringing a case had passed years earlier. In any case, she wasn't alleging identity theft, but forgery.

Robert Murray, a spokesman for USA Funds, agrees that Mrs. Brown's signature was forged. "It's absolutely a forgery," he says, "It \[the loan\] should never have been made."

But he says that USA Funds couldn't discharge the loan as a forgery because Mrs. Brown didn't return a required form in 2005, and that USA Funds must rigorously defend claims. "There are borrowers who want to get out of a legitimate debt," he says. "By the same token, we want to work with individuals who have a legitimate issue."

Ms. Drysdale, the legal–aid lawyer, finally sought to obtain a disability waiver for her client. That process took more than a year, and was achieved only after Ms. Drysdale asked for help from the Social Security Administration's ombudsman, who declined to comment.

In August 2009, the Education Department agreed that Mrs. Brown is permanently disabled, and discharged her obligation to repay the loan she never took out. The Treasury returned her withheld benefits in December.
by Ellen E. Schultz
Write to Ellen E. Schultz at ellen.schultz@wsj.com

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Almost the Secretary of Homeland Security Goes To Jail.



Bernard Kerik, 54, who as head of the New York City's police worked closely with former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani at the time of the September 11, 2001 attacks, pleaded guilty to the federal charges in November.

"I know I must be punished. Please allow me to return to my wife and two little girls as soon as possible to start a new path," Kerik said during sentencing, according to local media.

A former police detective, and once Giuliani's driver, Kerik headed the New York City jail system before taking charge of the police department in 2000.

His career began to unravel during background checks when President George W. Bush nominated him in 2004 to become Secretary of Homeland Security.

Kerik withdrew, but his legal troubles later embarrassed Giuliani in his unsuccessful bid for the 2008 Republican presidential nomination.

Along with pleading guilty to lying and evading taxes, Kerik admitted receiving apartment renovations from a construction firm suspected of organized crime ties and helping the company win city contracts.

"It is a very sad day when the former commissioner of the greatest police department in the world is sentenced to prison for base criminal conduct," U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara said in a statement.

"Today's sentencing of Bernard Kerik is one of the most powerful recent reminders that no one in this country is above the law."

The four-year sentence imposed by Judge Stephen Robinson in U.S. District Court in White Plains, New York exceeded the sentencing guidelines of less than three years, as laid out in Kerik's plea deal, but fell far short of the maximum possible term of 61 years.

Kerik will remain out on bail, under house arrest and wearing an electronic ankle monitor, until he begins his term on May 17.

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Black Woman Invented The Terminator.

Black Author wins The Matrix Copyright Infringement Case
This little known story has met a just conclusion, as Sophia Stewart, African American author of The Matrix will finally receive her just due from the copyright infringement of her original work!!!


A less than accurate newspaper article about Sophia Stewart and her case caused many to believe that she had won her copyright infringement suit claiming authorship of the Terminator and Matrix manuscripts and was about to receive a multi-billion dollar settlement. This 28 October 2004 article, penned by a second-year communications student for the Salt Lake Community College Globe, erred in mistaking Sophia Stewart's 4 October 2004 Los Angeles Federal Central District Court victory against a dismissal motion for her having eventually prevailed in her copywright imfringement suit. The article asserted Stewart "will recover damages from the films, The Matrix I, II and III, as well as The Terminator and its sequels" and would "soon receive one of the biggest payoffs in the history of Hollywood." What Sophia Stewart had won was the right to proceed with her case. This was a prediction not a fait accompli.

The Globe subsequently posted the following correction:
In reference to the recent article entitled "Mother of the Matrix Victorious," some information has been deemed misleading. Ms. Sophia Stewart has not yet won her case against Joel Silver, Time Warner and the Wachowski Bros. The decision on October 4th enabled Ms. Stewart to proceed with her case, as all attempts to have it dismissed were unsuccessful. Ms. Stewart's case will proceed through the Los Angeles Federal Central District Court of California.

Thanks,
The Globe Staff

(Author's NOTE) However, that is not the end of the story. Due to the size of the potential award, and the power of the Defendant, it is not inconceiveable that a condition of a potential settlement would have required Sophia Stewart to take a cash settlement and to make no more waves. It was not determined that she was not the victim of copywright imfringement. Indeed, this would have been a perfectly acceptable face saving conclusion to the litigation for Time Warner. It is such a pity that in this day and age, one can never accept the obvious as true. A critical thinker should always look to the less obvious and consider the possibility. Since truth is stronger than fiction, it is entirely feasible that the following story in the logical conclusion of the litigation set in motion by Sophia Stewart's law suit against Time Warner, et. al. for theft of intellectual property and copywright imfingement.


A six-year dispute has ended involving Sophia Stewart, the Wachowski Brothers, Joel Silver and Warner Brothers. Stewart's allegations, involving copyright infringement and racketeering, were received and acknowledged by the Central District of California, Judge Margaret Morrow presiding.

Stewart, a New Yorker who has resided in Salt Lake City for the past five years, will recover damages from the films, The Matrix I, II and III, as well as The Terminator and its sequels. She will soon receive one of the biggest payoffs in the history of Hollywood , as the gross receipts of both films and their sequels total over 2.5 billion dollars.

Stewart filed her case in 1999, after viewing the Matrix, which she felt had been based on her manuscript, 'The Third Eye,' copyrighted in 1981. In the mid-eighties Stewart had submitted her manuscript to an ad placed by the Wachowski Brothers, requesting new sci-fi works..

According to court documentation, an FBI investigation discovered that more than thirty minutes had been edited from the original film, in an attempt to avoid penalties for copyright infringement. The investigation also stated that 'credible witnesses employed at Warner Brothers came forward, claiming that the executives and lawyers had full knowledge that the work in question did not belong to the Wachowski Brothers.' These witnesses claimed to have seen Stewart's original work and that it had been 'often used during preparation of the motion pictures.' The defendants tried, on several occasions, to have Stewart's case dismissed, without success.


Stewart has confronted skepticism on all sides, much of which comes from Matrix fans, who are strangely loyal to the Wachowski Brothers. One on-line forum, entitled Matrix Explained has an entire section devoted to Stewart. Some who have researched her history and writings are open to her story.


Others are suspicious and mocking. 'It doesn't bother me,' said Stewart in a phone interview last week, 'I always knew what was true.'


Some fans, are unaware of the case or they question its legitimacy, due to the fact that it has received little to no media coverage. Though the case was not made public until October of 2003, Stewart has her own explanation, as quoted at aghettotymz.com :


'The reason you have not seen any of this in the media is because Warner Brothers parent company is AOL-Time Warner.... this GIANT owns 95 percent of the media... let me give you a clue as to what they own in the media business... New York Times papers/magazines, LA Times papers/magazines, People Magazine, CNN news, Extra, Celebrity Justice, Entertainment Tonight, HBO, New Line Cinema, DreamWorks, Newsweek, Village Roadshow and many, many more! They are not going to report on themselves. They have been suppressing my case for years.'


Fans who have taken Stewart's allegations seriously, have found eerie mythological parallels, which seem significant in a case that revolves around the highly metaphorical and symbolic Matrix series. Sophia, the Greek goddess of wisdom has been referenced many times in speculation about Stewart. In one book about the Goddess Sophia, it reads, 'The black goddess is the mistress of web creation spun in her divine matrix.'


Although there have been outside implications as to racial injustice (Stewart is African American), she does not feel that this is the case. 'This is all about the Benjamins,' said Stewart. 'It's not about money with me. It's about justice.'


Stewart's future plans involve a record label, entitled Popsilk Records, and a motion picture production company, All Eyez On Me, in reference to God. 'I wrote The Third Eye to wake people up, to remind them why God put them here. There's more to life than money,' said Stewart. 'My whole to the world is about God and good and about choice, about spirituality over 'technocracy'.'


If Stewart represents spirituality, then she truly has prevailed over the 'technocracy' represented in both the Terminator and the Matrix, and now, ironically, by their supposed creators.


Stewart is currently having discussions with CBS about a possible exclusive story and has several media engagements in the near future to nationally publicize her victory. June 13th 2004. Sophia Stewart's press release read: 'The Matrix & Terminator movie franchises have made world history and have ultimately changed the way people view movies and how Hollywood does business, yet the real truth about the creator and creation of these films continue to elude the masses because the hidden secret of the matter is that these films were created and written by a Black woman...a Black woman named Sophia Stewart. But Hollywood does not want you to know this fact simply because it would change history. Also it would encourage our Black children to realize a dream and that is...nothing is impossible for them to achieve!'

Greg Thomas, Editor

PRESS RELEASE.
December 23, 2008.

Screenplay writer Stewart, better known as Mother of the Matrix and author of the book the Third Eye, will soon be releasing her own version of the continuation of the series. The Matrix which was released in 1999 , which starred actors Kenau Reeves, Laurence Fishburne and Carrie Ann Moss was listed as one of the most successful box office hits in the history of the movie industry. Also, the movie featured the successful digital innovation that revolutionized cyber, techno, cinematography, special effects and was a first of it’s kind to do so, with much of the credit given to the original writer, Sophia Stewart .



Although Warner Brothers, Twentieth Century Fox, James Cameron, Joel Silver, Andy and Larry Wachowski were sued by Ms Stewart. in the U.S Federal Court, for illegal use, infringement, redevelopment, reproduction, distribution and promotion of Stewart’s copyrighted literary work entitled “The Third Eye” which was the source of the creation and development of the Matrix, Stewart feels, it is time to put forth more of the work.





For years moviegoers and Matrix fans around the world have been both analytical and critical to obvious missing links connecting the first Matrix Movie with it’s sequels The Matrix Reloaded (May, 2003) and The Matrix Revolutions (November, 2003). Ms Stewart states” It is very difficult to make effective sequels when you are not the original source of the ideology and philosophy of the work and this is where the audiences and fans of the Matrix was shortchanged.”



Sophia Stewart’s new release of M4 will finally address the questions that for years many fans have sought to have answered in the sequels of the Matrix.



M4 a live action film , will feature cyber, techno, cinematography, never before seen epic special effects and graphics, hidden code sequences, and unique concepts, that will surpass Stewart's creative work used to revolutionize the movie industry and that of the first Matrix Movie.





MATRX 4 THE EVOLUTION, which is currently in pre production, has already garnered a lot of attention from studios in the movie industry wanting a piece of the pie and is certainly being billed as the next blockbuster release project for Matrix fans and moviegoers worldwide.



Ginepri Capitol-Sega of wall street have expressed interest in the tunes of a $150 million dollars to continute the billion dollar franschise.Ginepri Capital is a Hedge Fund with well into the nine figures under active management and a leveraged capacity of approximately $4.6 billion.



It appears that interest in the making of Stewart's M4 is so intense, she has received phone calls from Hip Hop moguls such as Curtis Jackson a.k.a. 50 cent, who would like to be one of the Executive Producers on the movie. Global recognition and offers have come, as far as the Middle East, China, France, Japan, Ukraine, Italy and Germany.



Sophia Stewart has expressed interest in having the original cast, producers, and technical people of the Matrix Trilogies to continue her creativity.



FOR INFORMATION CONTACT:



Sophia Stewart

Matrix4TheMovie@yahoo.com





* We will set-up conference calls for Serious inquiries only

Posted: 12/26/2008 at 23:23 Read 11 times | 0 comments | Leave Comment
Recent Decision Order
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF UTAHCENTRAL DIVISION

SOPHIA STEWART,Plaintiff,vs.MICHAEL T. STOLLER, JONATHAN LUBELL, DEAN WEBB, GARYBROWN, and JOHN DOES I through X,

Defendants.MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER

Case No. 2:07CV552 DAK
This matter is before the court on (1) Defendant Gary S. Brown’s (“Mr. Brown) Motion to Dismiss or Change Venue to the Central District of Los Angeles, California; (2) DefendantDean Webb’s (“Mr. Webb”) Motion to Dismiss or in the Alternative, Motion to Change Venue;(3) Defendant Michael T. Stoller’s (“Mr. Stoller”) Motion to Dismiss and his Joinder in the other Motions to Change Venue; and (4) Defendant Jonathon Lubell’s (“Mr. Lubell”) Motion to Dismiss and Motion to Change Venue.
A hearing on the motions was held on June 25, 2008. At the hearing, Mr. Brown represented himself and appeared via telephone. Mr. Webb was represented by Kathleen Liuzzi.Mr. Stoller and Mr. Lubell represented themselves.

Plaintiff Sophia Stewart (“Ms. Stewart”) was represented by Kevin Moriarty. Before the hearing, the court carefully considered the memoranda and other materials submitted by the parties. Since taking the matter under advisement, the court has further considered the law and facts relating to these motions. NowCase 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008
Page 1 of 9 The following “facts” are taken from Plaintiff’s Complaint and are assumed to be true 1 for purposes of these motions to dismiss.2 being fully advised, the court renders the following Memorandum Decision and Order.
BACKGROUND 1 This case is primarily a legal malpractice action against Ms. Stewart’s attorneys in aprevious copyright infringement lawsuit (the “Infringement Action”) that she had filed inCalifornia in 2004. In her prior lawsuit, she alleged that Andy Wachowski, Larry Wachowski,Thea Bloom, Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation, Warner Bros. Entertainment, Inc., JamesCameron, Gale Ann Hurd and Joel Silver appropriated and infringed on her copyrighted material in creating the Matrix and Terminator Trilogies. Her case, however, was dismissed on May 18,2005, and judgment was entered against Ms. Stewart on June 14, 2005.In the instant case, Ms. Stewart alleges that the Infringement Action was dismissed because of Defendants’ malpractice, negligence, conspiracy and breaches of contract. Specifically she claims that summary judgment was entered against her in the underlying case because her attorneys–without her knowledge–failed to produce her for a deposition, neverconducted any discovery, and failed to respond to the defendant’s discovery requests, including failing to respond to requests for admissions, which facts were later deemed admitted.Defendants in the instant action have made two arguments for dismissal. First, theyargue that Ms. Stewart’s action is time-barred because California law applies, and the California statute of limitations for legal malpractice is one year. Because the one-year limitations periodexpired by no later than June 15, 2006, they contend that this action, which was filed on July 30,Case 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 2 of 9 In addition, Defendant Brown contends that the time by which Plaintiff had to 2commence an action against him was even earlier (May 17, 2006) because he withdrew from representing Plaintiff on May 18, 2005 due to his hospitalization for a heart attack.32007, is time-barred. Next, they argue that even if the action is not time-barred, Utah is thewrong venue because all Defendants reside in California, New Jersey, or Washington–and all thepertinent events occurred in Los Angeles. Thus, Defendants contend, this action should either be dismissed for improper venue or transferred to Los Angeles.Ms. Stewart, on the other hand, argues that Utah law applies to this action, and Utah’s statute of limitations for legal malpractice is four years, thus rendering this action timely. Ms.Stewart also contends that venue is proper in Utah because a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claims in this action occurred in Utah. Therefore, she urges thecourt to deny all the motions.

DISCUSSION:
WAS THE INSTANT ACTION TIMELY FILED?
The question of whether the action is time-barred hinges on which state’s law applies. If California law applies, the action is time barred, but if Utah law applies, the action was timely filed. Defendants contend that courts should look to the law where the harm occurred, which,they claim, is in California. They contend that Ms. Stewart filed her lawsuit in California, theattorneys were all admitted (or were granted permission ) to practice in the Central District ofCalifornia, and the “harmful conduct,” which they characterize as the dismissal of the action,occurred in California. 2Case 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 3 of 94Ms. Stewart, on the other hand, argues that Utah’s four-year statute of limitations appliesin this case. She retained Defendants at various times beginning in 2004, and all events relevantto her claims in the Infringement Action occurred between 2004 and 2006. The instant action was filed in August 2007, within the four-year limitations period. Thus, according to Ms.Stewart, Defendants' motions to dismiss pursuant to F.R.C.P. 12(b)(6) must be denied.A federal court sitting in a diversity action follows the procedural law of the forum state,regardless of whether the court applies the substantive law of the forum state or another state.Rocky Mountain Helicopters, Inc. v. Bell Helicopter Texatron, Inc., 24 F.3d 125, 128 (10 Cir. th1994). Utah follows the traditional rule that "statutes of limitation are essentially procedural innature," and that "under a general conflicts of law analysis, the limitations period of the forum applies." Records v. Briggs, 887 P.2d 864, 870 (Utah Ct. App. 1994) (citing Lee v. Gaufin, 867P.2d 572, 575 (Utah 1993), Jackett v. Los Angeles Dep't of Water & Power, 771 P.2d 1074,1075-76 (Utah Ct. App. 1989), and Pan Energy v. Martin, 813 P.2d 1142, 1145-46 (Utah 1991));see also Sun Oil Co. v. Wortmann, 486 U.S. 717 (1988) (application of the forum state's statutesof limitation is consistent with the traditional view that such statutes are procedural and is consistent with the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the U.S. Constitution); Fin. Bancorp, Inc. v.Pingree & Dahle, Inc., 880 P.2d 14, 16 (Utah Ct. App. 1993) (Utah follows the majority position that limitation periods are generally procedural in nature, and thus, Utah’s statutes of limitationapply to actions brought in Utah.”).Accordingly, in the instant action, this court applies Utah’s limitations period for legal malpractice claims. Because Utah law provides a four-year limitations period, Plaintiff’s actionCase 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 4 of 95is not time-barred.
IS VENUE PROPER IN UTAH?
Next, Defendants argue that venue is improper in Utah, and thus the action should bedismissed or transferred. Defendants conclusorily argue that all the substantial events took place in California and that none of the Defendants lives in Utah. In contrast, Ms. Stewart argues that venue is appropriate in Utah because a substantial part of the events and/or omissions giving riseto her claim occurred here. Under 28 U.S.C. 1391(a)(2), venue in diversity cases is proper in any judicial districtwhere “a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred.” This language has been interpreted to allow for the fact that a substantial part of the events may haveoccurred in more than one district and “venue may be proper even if contacts with another district were more substantial.” Mohr v. Margolis, Ainswoth & Kinlaw Consulting, Inc., 434 F.Supp. 2d 1051 (D. Kan. 2006).

Federal district courts have held that the "substantial part" requirement of Section1392(a)(2) is satisfied where the plaintiff resides in the forum state and the defendants havecontacts with plaintiff in the forum state related to the subject of the action. In Furr v. Aguilar, the District Court for the District of Colorado, the court considered a motion to dismiss forimproper venue in a case involving claims by a Colorado resident against a California law firm,which had defended the Colorado resident in an action in California state court. Furr, 2005 WL1801627 (D. Colo. July 28, 2005) (unpublished decision). The court noted that the law firm'snormal duties in representing the Colorado resident included informing him of the status of theCase 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 5 of 96case, any offers to settle and other matters raised in the action. The court also found that such correspondence occurred via telephone from the law firm's offices in California, and that the attorney-client relationship was established with a resident of Colorado. Based on thesecontacts, which were related to the malpractice claims at issue, the court concluded that theplaintiff had demonstrated that a substantial part of the relevant events had occurred in Colorado,and denied defendants' motion to dismiss.In Stein v. Stein, the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas held that plaintiffs, whowere residents of Kansas, met their burden of demonstrating proper venue under Section1391(a)(2). Stein, 184 Fed. Appx. 808, 2006 WL 1892580 (D. Kan. July 11, 2006) (unpublisheddecision). In that case, plaintiffs, who were residents of Kansas, sued Washington residents anda Washington LLC for breach of contract, fraud, unjust enrichment, breach of duty of good faithand fair dealing, and breach of fiduciary duty. The plaintiffs alleged that they had contractedwith defendants to make an equity investment in the LLC's business enterprise, and based on thatalleged contract plaintiffs had obtained a line of credit from a Kansas bank for the benefit of thedefendants. The court found that the alleged contract was sent to plaintiffs in Kansas, plaintiffsperformed their part of the alleged contract in this state, and any of the alleged fraudulentrepresentations were made via facsimile, e-mail or in person to plaintiffs in Kansas. Thus,Kansas was an appropriate venue under Section 1391(a)(2).In this case, Plaintiff has set forth sufficient allegations to demonstrate that Utah is aproper venue under Section 1392(a)(2).
Plaintiff is a Utah resident. (First Amended Complaintat ¶ 1). She was contacted by each of Defendants at her residence in Utah, and agreed to retainCase 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 6 of 97each in Utah. (Aff. of Sophia Stewart at ¶¶ 3-6, 9-10). She executed an engagement letter withMessrs. Lubell, Brown, and Webb in Utah. (Id. ¶ 6). She had telephone conversations andcorresponded with each of the Defendants from Utah. (Id. ¶ 7, 11, 14, 17).
Plaintiff did not attend any hearings in California, based on the advice of one or more of the Defendants. (Id. ¶23). Defendants sent her bills for services at her address in Utah. (Id. ¶ 22). These contactswere over the course of the Infringement Action, from the spring of 2004 through summer 2006.(Id. ¶ 3-23). Like the plaintiffs in Furr, Plaintiff has brought this action against her formerattorneys for malpractice, who purposefully and regularly directed their contacts toward a Utah resident when they were retained and throughout their handling of the Infringement Action. Like the plaintiffs in Stein, Plaintiff contends that she complied with her obligations with respect tothe attorney-client relationship and the prosecution of the Infringement Action in Utah. Thus,the court finds that these contacts were sufficient to qualify as a "substantial part" of the actionsand omissions giving rise to Plaintiff's claims, and thereby satisfy the requirements for venue in Utah under Section 1391(a)(2).

SHOULD THE CASE BE TRANSFERRED?
Defendants again conclusorily argue that the court should transfer the case to the CentralDistrict of California. Plaintiff contends that Defendants have failed to meet their burden ofdemonstrating that this action should be transferred. In considering whether to transfer venue, acourt considers the following factors: a plaintiff's choice of forum; the accessibility of witnessesand other sources of proof, including the availability of compulsory process to insure attendanceof witnesses; the cost of making the necessary proof; questions as to the enforceability of aCase 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 7 of 98judgment if one is obtained; relative advantages and obstacles to a fair trial; difficulties that mayarise from congested dockets; the possibility of the existence of questions arising in the area ofconflict of laws; the advantage of having a local court determine questions of local law; and, allother considerations of a practical nature that make a trial easy, expeditious and economical.Chrysler Credit Corp. v. Country Chrysler, Inc., 928 F.2d 1509, 1516 (10th Cir. 1991) (quotingTex. Gulf Sulphur Co. v. Ritter, 371 F.2d 145, 147 (10th Cir. 1967)). A court must give greatweight to plaintiff's choice of forum. KCJ Corp. v. Kinetic Concepts, Inc., 18 F. Supp. 2d 1212,1214 (D. Kan. 1998). Unless the balance strongly favors the movant, plaintiff's forum choiceshould rarely be disturbed. Scheidt, 956 F.2d at 965. "Merely shifting the inconvenience from one side to the other . . . is not a permissible justification for a change of venue.” Id. at 966. Inexercising its discretion, “the Court must ‘adjudicate motions for transfer according to an‘individualized, case-by-case consideration of convenience and fairness.’” Chrysler, 928 F.2d at1516 (quoting Stewart Org. v. Ricoh Corp., 487 U.S. 22, 29 (1988)).In addition, the party moving to transfer a case pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) bears theburden of establishing that the existing forum is inconvenient. Chrysler Credit Corp. v. CountryChrysler, Inc., 928 F.2d 1509, 1515 (10 Cir. 1991). Defendants have failed to carry their thburden in this case. Given the weight assigned to Plaintiff’s choice of forum, the fact that atleast some of the Defendants would have to travel in any event, and the other factors that a court considers, Defendants simply have failed to demonstrated that the action should be transferred to California.Case 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 8 of 99CONCLUSIONAccordingly, for the foregoing reasons, (1) Defendant Gary S. Brown’s Motion toDismiss (docket # 14) is DENIED and his Motion to Change Venue to the Central District of LosAngeles, CA (docket # 15) is DENIED; (2) Defendant Dean Webb’s Motion to Dismiss (docket# 18) is DENIED and his Alternative Motion to Change Venue (docket # 26) is DENIED; (3)Defendant Michael T. Stoller’s Motion to Dismiss (docket # 20) is DENIED and his Motion toChange Venue (by joining in other Defendants’ motions) is DENIED; (4) Defendant JonathonLubell’s Motion to Dismiss (docket #21) is DENIED, and his Motion to Change Venue (docket# 22) is DENIED. Defendants are directed to file an Answer to the Complaint by no later thanSeptember 23, 2008. DATED this 28 day of August, 2008. thBY THE COURT:DALE A. KIMBALLUnited States District JudgeCase 2:07-cv-00552-DAK Document 35 Filed 08/28/2008 Page 9 of 9

Posted: 11/10/2008 at 16:32 Read 42 times | 0 comments | Leave Comment
FRAUD REOPENS THE MATRIX CASE
In 1981-83 an Epic sci-fi story was written by Sophia Stewart Titled "THE THIRD EYE". It is an epic science fiction work with Biblical subliminization. This body of work was copy righted by the Library of Congress. The book is out now, that tells a story within a story. The Book was written for the Matrix fans and the People who want to know the TRUTH about the Matrix, Terminator and The Woman who created this great body of work, So take the Red pill and stay in wonderland and see how deep the rabbit hole goes.FRAUD REOPENS THE MATRIX CASE